Galdoni by Cheree Alsop is a young adult novel, first in a series that teeters on the edges of science fiction/fantasy and paranormal.
THE BLURB:
"This is the Arena, and here we live to die.” These are the words carved into a holding cell where genetically-altered gladiators, the winged humans called Galdoni, are trained to fight. Kale, rescued by three high school students and nursed back from the brink of death, is given the chance to experience life as a human. When he is captured, he has to use what he learned in the world outside the Academy in order to free the other Galdoni and return to the human girl he loves.
Dark and exciting, Galdoni pushes the boundaries of love in a world of violence.
MY THOUGHTS:
The pages of Galdoni are filled with what would make a decent basis for part of an engaging story. The writing in this book is pretty good, but the plot left much to be desired.
I think it would have been better to have started the story while Kale was still at the Academy, see his life there, believe the lies he and the others are told about their existence. Then you have a little more of a clue going into the story, plus you get to be shocked right along with Kale when he learns the truth. Instead all we get is the piece of the story after Kale has left the Academy, and a small portion at the end when he returns to the Arena that is the seat of all the conflict in the story.
There are too many plot holes here, or questions that aren't answered to the readers' satisfaction. Some examples: we are told the mess hall is guarded more after the Academy reopens, but then Kale stands on a table and gives a rebellious speech before guards show up. If the Galdoni are so strong and such skilled fighters, how are the humans able to oppress them? All the guards have are whips and night sticks. Sure, it'll hurt if you get hit with one, but we are led to believe the Galdoni have superhuman talent in fighting and intense training. It seems they could take the guards down. ESPECIALLY in the end fight when the Galdoni are armed with swords and maces, but still they cower when the guards show up. And are there no female Galdoni? I can't even remember now why the Arena closed in the first place. But why in the world would they choose to loose these alleged "bloodthirsty animals", completely unfamiliar with how to live in the outside world, out into society? And then all of a sudden change your mind and take them all back? The explanations were thin and unconvincing, when they were there at all.
The characters here are likeable enough, but not very fleshed out, and the romance was laughable. It was basically a classic case of instalove. After a handful of interactions, none of which are anything special, the two people involved suddenly proclaim their love for one another. And if Brie's eyes filled with tears ONE MORE TIME....!
And I have a guess as to who knocked a character on the head after the end fight, but it's never explained.
The redeeming qualities include the fact that the author, as mentioned above, is a decent writer. But sadly, the plot was lacking.
MY RATING:
2.5 booksies